This morning was the start of our new swim class at a nearby YMCA. M has been wanting to do this for ages with the kids, and we finally got around to signing up. Getting to the 9AM class after losing an hour last night was a bit of a crazed rush, but we made it in plenty of time.
We had a few minutes before class, so we could stand and look through the glass wall into the pool. The kids seemed interested, and it’s not as though this was the first time they’d seen or been in a pool. When we went in, Rebecca was not thrilled by the man swimming past her while she walked along the pool deck, but they did fine. Having an adult for each kid is always a nice perk, of course.
There were only three of us in the class, so yes, my family made up 2/3 of the group. The other girl was about 15-16 months old, so at least they were of a similar age range. The class is technically for 6-to-18 month olds, and our kids are 19 months, but I figure better to err on the younger side for their first class. Especially since the next age group is 19-36 months, which is an awfully large range.
Anyways, we sang a quick hello song, and the teacher encouraged us to put a little floatie on the kids (even though we wouldn’t exactly be letting go of them) and kick back and forth across the pool. The kids weren’t really into it, but we did it anyways. Then, singing a little song and going in a circle (kids not at all pleased), she suggested we blow in their faces and try to dunk them. I didn’t think that was so wise, but she strongly encouraged it, so M and I played along. As predicted, there was much screaming by our pair. The screaming didn’t stop until we left the pool.
Here’s where I had a problem. Aside from the fact that I’m not convinced the “blow in their face” technique works that well on 19-month-olds, after Daniel was hysterical for a solid 5 minutes, I stepped off to the side to try and remove him from the situation and calm him down. I was immediately instructed to come back in, that I shouldn’t “send a bad message” by taking him out, that we should basically just let them scream and continue about our business. That I didn’t want to send the message that something is wrong by taking him out for a minute. I got practically a mini-lecture at the end of class about how crying is fine, that I shouldn’t “give in” to it, etc.

You all know, I don’t have a particularly difficult time being the hard-ass, as a rule. I don’t overreact to crying, temper tantrums, etc.. I don’t have a problem pushing my kids outside of their comfort zone in the name of learning. But my whole thing about swim class is to teach my kids to enjoy and feel comfortable in the water. And while I obviously have zero training as a swim instructor, I feel like maybe the approach could have used a lot more gentle encouragement and a lot less just powering through the screams. I fear that this approach is only going to lead to my kids beginning to scream the moment we pull on the swim diapers. Especially since Daniel, for one, was really warming up to the pool in Florida, only to freak out today at the Y.
I can’t decide whether to give the class another chance or just cut our losses and try to find another one. On the one hand, this was just one session. Maybe it’ll get better. On the other hand, if this is going to breed some kind of pool phobia, I’d like to get the hell out as soon as possible.
M also points out there was a bit of an “assembly line” mentality to the teacher. She was going straight from one class into the next, no break. Didn’t learn the kids names (there were only three of us!), sang the song, kicking activity one, kicking activity two, circle, dunk, ball, goodbye song (what were those names again?), get out of the pool, start the next class. I can understand that would be a hard way to teach. But I sort of don’t care. My experience was that she was not engaged with the kids at all, not encouraging, not adapting to anyone’s needs. And that doesn’t seem worth scrambling to get out of the house early on a Sunday morning.
Moms of older kids, I’d love to hear your thoughts on this one. Teacher engagement issues aside, did it work for your kids to just push through the initial protests and screams? If I knew this was going to pay off, I’d totally stick with it. But I need to know it’s likely to actually go somewhere positive, and not lead to a kid who’s afraid of the water. Or, do you think my mommy-spidey-sense is right and this is not a good approach? Any swim teachers out there want to weigh in?
And as a P.S. to this day… within about five minutes playing in the tub, we had Daniel putting half his face in the water, trying to blow bubbles, thinking it was the funniest thing he’s ever seen. This is not a kid with an inherent fear of the water.
